🧀 A2/A2 cheese. What's the big deal? It's the way all cheese used to be. LEARN MORE.

Yes, raw milk naturally sours! Here's why and what you need to know.

written by

Marie Reedell

posted on

December 6, 2024

raw-milk-sours.jpg

Raw milk. Such a simple old fashioned food. But, as a society over the past few generations, we've lost so much common sense knowledge about it. One big example is ---

Raw milk sours! It's a natural thing and impossible to stop in the fridge. 

This blog post will dive into all things sour... as it relates to raw milk. Keep reading to learn more.

Why Raw Milk Sours

The short answer is --- it's fermenting and turning into cheese! The living microbiology in raw milk is digesting the lactose (milk sugar) and making lactic acid. This is what makes raw milk naturally get more and more sour over time.

When I say "living microbiology", I'm specifically talking about lactic acid bacteria. Those are the ones that eat lactose. There are many kinds in raw milk, including Lactobacillus, Streptococcus thermophilus, Enterococcus, and Lactococcus. 

These lactic acid bacteria are probiotic! This is why raw milk is known for improving gut health. It's like a completely natural probiotic pill.

It's important to note that raw milk has all of the living microbiology intact. That includes microorganisms that aren't in the cow but around the cow. Yeasts and fungal spores come from the air. And potentially harmful bacteria can come from manure. This is why we keep our barn, cows, and equipment meticulously clean!

These outside-of-the-cow microorganisms do NOT eat lactose. So the fact that the milk sours does NOT indicate danger. It's a palatability issue, not a safety issue.

Instead, souring milk simply becomes more and more probiotic. The more sour the milk, the higher the amounts of lactic acid bacteria. The busier those bacteria were fermenting, eating the lactose, and creating lactic acid, the more their colonies grew.

What Affects The Souring Process

How fast raw milk sours depends on (1) how clean the milking process was (after all, lactic acid bacteria can grow on equipment); (2) how fast the milk was cooled down; and (3) how it's stored.

The first two are 100% our responsibility. The third point we share. It's our job to keep your milk cold until you get it. Then it's your responsibility to properly store it at home.

Once you get your raw milk, how fast it sours depends on temp and time. The higher the temp, the faster the fermentation. The longer it sits, the more it ferments. 

Storage Tips

COUNTER: If you want to purposefully sour your milk, the counter is the way to go. When fresh raw milk is kept on the counter, it will start to sour overnight and will become unpalatable within a few days.

If you want your raw milk to sour very quickly, then leave it at a higher temp. Remember that all the wonderful properties of raw begin to break down when heated above 110F... and that includes the lactic acid bacteria! So never store raw milk you want to sour over 110F.

FRIDGE: When kept in the fridge, raw milk typically starts to develop a sour flavor in 7-14 days. It will likely become too sour to palate in about 10-21 days. 

There's no way to stop the fermentation, but there is a way to optimize it.

The ideal storage temp for raw milk is 33-38F. The average fridge is usually 35-40F, so using a thermometer will help you figure out if your fridge is the perfect temp. Also keep in mind that different parts of your fridge may be different temps. The lowest, farthest back part of your fridge is usually the coldest and therefore likely the best spot for your milk.

FREEZERYes, you can freeze raw milk for up to 6 months! Once thawed, it may become clumpy. Simply shake to recombine. 

Freezing raw milk pauses fermentation. The living microbiology will (mostly) come back to life when thawed, and then your milk will continue to ferment and get sour. 

Keep in mind that the longer raw milk is frozen, the more probiotic loss. Because of this, I don't recommend freezing for more than 6 months.

*An important note it that some people can detect a undesirable flavor difference in previously frozen milk. So, if you haven't done it before, I recommend freezing a small amount first. Test it and see how you like it. You definitely don't want to waste any milk!

How To Use Sour Milk

Whether for your human or furry family, sour milk is 100% fine to consume. It's not a safety issue but a palatability issue. 

CHOCOLATE MILK: This is a way to mask the sourness. Heat 1 cup water, 1 cup cocoa powder, and 1/2 tsp sea salt in a pot on the stove. Once smooth, stir in 1 cup maple syrup. Now you have chocolate syrup to flavor your sour milk with! I usually use about 1 cup of chocolate syrup to a gallon of milk.

RICOTTA CHEESE: This is my favorite way to use up sour milk. Heat 1/2 gallon of sour milk and 1/2 tsp of sea salt in a pot on the stove until steaming (around 185F). Lower the heat and add 3 Tbsp of lemon juice (or vinegar). Stir for about 2 minutes. You'll notice the curds separating from the whey. Turn the heat off and let it sit for 20 minutes. Then, pour into a cheesecloth-lined colander set inside a large bowl. For a creamier cheese, let sit 3-5 minutes. For a firmer cheese, let sit up to 20 minutes. Enjoy immediately or store in the fridge for up to 3 days.

COOKING AND BAKING: Guess what? For any recipe that calls for buttermilk, you can sub with sour milk! Think sour milk pancakes, marinating chicken, or homemade ranch dressing.

Have You Tried Triple E's Raw Milk?

How long does yours last? How do you store it? What do you do with sour milk?

More from the blog

A2/A2 cheese. What's the big deal? It's the way all cheese used to be.

Have you heard about the A2/A2 dairy thing?  Sure, I could get into all the science-y stuff behind it. The beta-casein protein structure, the peptides it breaks down into, the mechanisms for how it could cause damage, etc. But... that seems a little complicated. The way I like to think about the A2/A2 dairy thing is that it's the old fashioned kind. Here's why: A long time ago, cows underwent a genetic mutation that made them produce a new kind of protein - A1. You see, all mammals naturally produce milk with 100% A2 protein in it (humans, goats, sheep, mice, whales, etc)... with one exception: COWS.  A couple thousand years ago, cows in Europe were put indoors in cities. They weren't on pasture and couldn't exercise. People started to feed them grain and byproducts from making whisky or beer. They were living an unnatural lifestyle, eating an unnatural diet. The cows were stressed. And what do living things do under stress? They adapt and sometimes mutate.  Those European cows underwent a genetic mutation that made them produce a new kind of protein in their milk - A1. And then, those cows made their way to the US. And now, basically all cow dairy in the US has a mix of A1 and A2 proteins (also called A1/A2). The A2 protein is the old fashioned kind. And, gee I'm not surprised that the old fashioned kind is easier to digest and works best for most.  This is especially true for people from eastern countries like India and China. Why? The cows there didn't undergo that mutation. They still produce A2/A2 milk. People there haven't had time to acclimate to the A1 protein. When someone is intolerant to A1 protein, they generally have tummy troubles. The symptoms can be similar to lactose intolerance: stomach pains, bloating, diarrhea, constipation, flatulence, etc. Over time, those issues can develop into more chronic issues like IBS or colitis. I've heard from so many people who haven't had dairy in years and then try A2/A2 and rejoice - "I can eat dairy again!" Did you know that all of our cheeses are now A2/A2?  That's right! And since cheese basically has the most protein of any other dairy item, it's a great place to start with A2/A2.  We plan to convert our entire herd to A2/A2 by the end of the year. That means that ALL of our dairy will be A2/A2 soon. Stay tuned! Do you handle A2/A2 dairy better, or does it not matter for you? What are the top things you look for when shopping for dairy? I'd love to hear from you! Comment below or contact us 😊

Mmmm... spring milk. Super special when you eat from a natural farmer.

Back in the day when all farming was natural, spring was extra special.  First off, spring feels really good after a long winter. There's the happy emergence of yellow daffodils and pink cherry flowers, the sounds of birds chirping and bugs buzzing, and the warm sun on your skin. But, the most exciting spring thing for a grass farmer like me and for a grass milk shopper like you is when the pasture turns from brown to bright green. When the cows are eating the first growth of 100% fresh spring grass - yeehaw! That means spring milk - the best dairy of the year! You see, when cows are fed outside on real pasture and are raised in harmony with nature, the milk changes throughout the year. There's variation that's in line with nature. In spring, the milk is hands down the best.  When you eat from a natural farmer, there are 3 things to look for with spring milk (or butter or cream or yogurt): The yellowest color. The bright spring grass means yellower milk. You're seeing the extra spring beta carotene in there! It's a sure way to know that your milk was 100% grass fed. The creamiest texture. Spring milk is loaded with more fat than other times of the year. You may notice the cream line on the milk get heftier. It's a perfect time for butter making. The most flavor. Since fat holds flavor and spring milk has more fat... that means the most flavorful milk is spring milk. Plus, when cows eat from biodiverse pastures like mine, it has a nuanced taste. Some may call it grassy or earthy. I call is straight up yummy. And, beyond what you can see and taste, spring milk is known for having max nutrition. Us humans are innately smart at stuff like this. When it naturally looks better and tastes better, it often means it nourishes you better, too! On my farm, 100% spring milk started a couple weeks ago. Now's the time to enjoy the dairy at its best! Have you noticed a difference in the milk or butter lately? Do you love the spring and spring dairy? I'd love to hear what you think! Comment below 😊-----PS: Did you know that, in nature, calving season is spring? We follow that natural cycle with most of our cows. That means we had a lot of mama cows that just gave birth!

Why corn & soy free? Here's an old fashioned standpoint.

In case you didn't know, over the past few years, we've transitioned all of our animals to be corn & soy free. Our dairy and beef and lamb have always been 100% grass fed. It's nothing new and simply the most natural way. I'm more talking about our animals that need supplemental feed in addition to what they forage for in the woods or at pasture - pigs, chickens, laying hens, and turkeys. There is just one exception: our GMO-free eggs. We're offering them now simply because we don't have enough corn & soy free eggs for everyone. They're the second best option around. Once our corn & soy free flock gets big enough, we'll likely discontinue the GMO-free eggs. But why? Why go corn & soy free? What's the big deal? Recently, I've heard a bunch of farms touting low PUFAs or having great omega 6/3 ratios. Well, that's all fine and well. It's always nice to have science back up what you're doing.  But, it's not really about that for me and my brother Phil. Sometimes it's softer, sometimes just by doing things that are innately natural lead to better health. The scientific whys and hows seem to constantly be changing, but the fact that natural is better has been a constant for a loooong time. Forget PUFAs. Forget omegas. Going corn & soy free is honestly the most old fashioned, most natural way of doing things in our confusing modern world of agriculture. Here are 5 reasons why (as it mostly relates to chickens): Chickens naturally forage for small grains, not big ones like corn and soy. If we go back in time, chickens were scavengers. They'd live on a farm or homestead and mostly fend for themselves. They would find kitchen scraps in the compost pile (veggies and grain and even meat). They would find spilled feed from other animals and eat that. And of course they would forage for grasses and bugs and seeds. And when foraging, they'd usually go for smaller seeds. Think about how big a grass seed is. It's small, much smaller than a large corn kernel or soybean. A modern, unnatural diet of mainly corn & soy can lead to health issues in animals. Here are a few problems that can arise: It's hard for chickens to digest corn and soy. Trying to do it over and over again can lead to digestive issues. For example, corn is high in starch and ferments easily. Chickens eating too much corn can have intestinal distress. Or, another example is that soy is high in anti-nutrients like lectins. This can interfere with how well a bird digests protein and absorbs nutrients.It can also lead to nutritional imbalances. For example, soy is high in anti-nutrients like lectins. Overconsumption can interfere with how well a bird digests protein and absorbs nutrients.It can lead to gaining weight and growing too fast. It's just unnatural. It can lead to issues with muscles, bones, joints, and the heart. Birds that grow too quickly are more prone to broken bones and lameness. We can avoid modern GMOs with certainty. No risk of cross pollination. Sure, corn and soy have been around for thousands of years. But, today's versions are nothing like they used to be. They've been hybridized and genetically modified. And because of the ridiculous amount of fields filled with GMO corn & soy, there's a pretty good chance of cross pollination nowadays. Eliminating corn and soy also eliminates the risk of anything GMO being in your food. Corn & soy are, more often than not, farmed with modern conventional practices. Those are usually bad for the environment and the future of soil. Corn & soy are the top 2 crops in the US. 90%+ that's grown is GMO. And that means that the farming practices are uber conventional.  Tilling, fertilizing with synthetic stuff, spraying lots of chemicals (including glyphosate), etc. These practices usually lead to some big problems environmentally: soil erosion, topsoil loss, loss of microbiology in the soil, loss of ecosystems, pollution in many forms, the list could go on and on!  Feeding a natural diet means healthier animals and therefore more nutrition for you! This is just common sense, right? When you eat better, you are healthier. And when it comes to farming, when you have healthier animals, they produce nutrient-dense foods! We do our best to give our animals the most biologically appropriate, most digestible, most bioavailable foods we can. It's really for the health of everything! What do you choose corn & soy free? Is it the PUFA/omega thing or something else?